Saturday July 25, 2020: Cup or Chalice?

Many of you, I am sure, have seen the Indiana Jones movies. Particularly the original one, Raiders of the Lost Ark. One of the more memorable scenes for me was the one where Indy (we are on first name basis with each other, don’t you know) is trying to decide which is the vessel that Christ would have used at the last supper. If he drinks from the correct one…his Father is saved from a gunshot wound. If the wrong one? Both he and his Father die. As he scans all the choices, he chooses the wooden one. The simple one. Instead of the golden vessels that dominate his options. He chooses wisely since, in his determination, Christ was a simple carpenter and would not have chosen a more ornate vessel.

I thought of this today when meditating on the readings. In 2nd Corinthians Paul says that we hold these treasures in Earthen Vessels, not gold ones. In Jesus’ time, clay pots were common and dispensable. If they broke, they were replaced and not repaired. They were also weak so they did break often. There was nothing outwardly noticeable about them at all. The vessels did not draw attention to themselves at all. And to the people of the day, they would never put anything of great value inside a clay pot.

But we also know that Jesus never did anything in a way that everyone expected. Common sense would have dictated that such a great treasure as the message of the world’s salvation would best be carried by the great leaders of the day. Kings, princes, military leaders. The gold vessels of humanity. But who in fact did He pick? Twelve ordinary, sinful men. Even one who would betray Him. These were not gold vessels. These were very much the clay pots, the EARTHEN vessels of the time. Weak men and women who would be easily broken and replaceable by society’s standards.

But why? Why use “common” people to carry the greatest message man has every encountered? For two reasons, I think. One is that the message should outshine the bearer. The vessel should not take away from what it holds. It is not the oyster shell that is magnificent. It is the pearl inside. It is the humble among us that allows the word of the Gospel to shine and not try to get in its way. The Mother of James and John in Matthew’s Gospel did not get this. She wanted her sons to sit at the right and left hand of Jesus in His kingdom. She wanted them to be front and center. Christ’s response was that the first should be last and should serve rather than to be served. To be earthen vessels. In the same chapter of Matthew as this reading is the parable of the vineyard workers. The story where those hired at the end of the day received the same wage as those hired at the beginning. The first shall be last.

Secondly, we are all weak, fragile people. But we are also called to carry God’s message of salvation. This message is not a “top down” message but a grass roots one. Ordinary people carrying an extraordinary message. It is not reserved for the few but offered to many, regardless of their standing in society. Power is from God, as St. Paul says, not from man. We may have cracks in our outer being but through those cracks the inner life that we carry, Christ, can shine through.

It is fitting that today is the Feast of St. James. While he did not sit at Jesus’ right or left hand, he did drink from the same cup as Christ. He suffered martyrdom as Jesus predicted for him. Tradition says that he preached the Gospel in Spain and he returned to Jerusalem where he was beheaded by Herod Agrippa. His remains returned to Spain where they were buried and then discovered. They are kept in the cathedral at Santiago de Compestella in Galicia, Spain. It is the destination of the famed pilgrimage walk, the Camino de Santiago. Because of his efforts, this earthen vessel has inspired millions of people to walk hundreds of miles since the 9th century to the place of his burial. And encounter Christ along The Way.

Finally, one last point. I know many of you may be saying, “if we are to be earthen vessels, why did we change from saying “Cup” to “Chalice” during the Eucharistic Prayer? I had been concerned about the same thing, so I did a little research. Obviously Jesus did not speak English and the Bible was not written in English. Likely in Aramean and most translations come from the Greek, and later from Latin. There is no word, “cup”, in any of these languages. They are kasa, poterion and calix respectively. All can translate as either cup or chalice with “chalice” being closest to the Latin. In addition, the mass is ceremony. Where we offer the best that we can as we re-present Christ’s sacrifice. Thus, the election to use a more ornate vessel during the mass. And, in English, it is a chalice that we use for this occasion.

“We hold a treasure not made of gold. In earthen vessels, wealth untold. One treasure only. The Lord. The Christ. In Earthen Vessels”.

(Earthen Vessels by John Foley)

About the Author

Hello! My name is John Ciribassi. I live in Carol Stream, IL in the USA. My wife Elise and I are parishioners at Corpus Christi Catholic Church. We have two adult daughters. One lives in Senegal, West Africa with her husband and her 3 sons. The other teaches Anthropology at the University of Oslo, Norway. We also have a home in Mainesburg, Pa in the North Central part of Pennsylvania. My wife and I are both retired veterinarians, and my specialty is in animal behavior. I attended college and veterinary school in Illinois, where I met my wife who is from the Chicago area, and the rest is history! My hobbies include Racquetball, Pickleball, Off Road Motorcycle Riding, Hiking and Camping. I continue to enjoy the opportunity to offer what little insight I have on the scriptures. But I have always felt that the scriptures can speak for themselves. My job is just to shine a little light on them for people who maybe don't have the time to look into the readings deeply. I hope you enjoy and find value in my writings. I continue to be grateful for this opportunity.

Author Archive Page

10 Comments

  1. This is lovely and very simplified for understanding.
    I come here daily for reflections and commentaries about daily readings and to say the least I am always satisfied. I pray your inspiration never seizes.. 🙏🙏

    Reading about yourself and learning both your daughters visit Africa gave me another reason to smile because I am a Cameroonian 🇨🇲 Central or West Africa 🤗

  2. God bless you, John for the nice reflection.

    God calls all!

    What is important is the message, not the carrier.

  3. Thanks John…great reflection! Yes, we often forget or miss the message when we focus on the messenger.

  4. Some thoughts to share: A “Cracked Pot” story

    An elderly woman had large large pots, each hung on the ends of a pole which she carried across her shoulder. One of the pots had a crack in it, while the other was perfect. The woman used the pots to carry water from the stream to her house. The perfect pot always delivered a full pot of water, while the cracked pot delivered only half. Even though the pot was cracked the woman continued to use them both for a length of time.

    The perfect pot was proud of its accomplishment but the cracked pot considered itself to be a failure. One day the cracked pot told the woman to discard it because it leaked. But the woman gently replied, “Did you not notice that there are flowers growing on your side of the path, but not on the side of the other pot? I know you have this flaw, and so I planted flower seeds on your side of the path. Even with your flaw you are capable of producing something beautiful.”

    We are all cracked pots with innumerable flaws. But God has sown his word anywhere and everywhere, knowing that even with our flaws we can and will one day produce a masterpiece.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published.