Don’t Ask; Don’t Tell

JairusAlthough I am a big fan of the gospels, there are moments when Jesus’ words and actions truly baffle me. As God’s Son who was sent from Heaven to save the world, it stands to reason that He would want to reveal Himself in big ways so that people would spread the word about Him, rally to His side and help usher in the Kingdom of God right on schedule. Instead, He is consistently inconsistent about publicity causing me to wonder, “What’s up with that?”

In Mark’s Gospel, when Jesus exorcises a possessed man and refuses to let him join His band of followers He tells him to return to his home and to tell his family what all has occurred. A few passages later, he raises Jairus’ daughter from the dead, but this time He gives strict orders not to talk about it. Quite frankly, this makes no sense to me.

I understand that Jesus was not seeking fame or a reputation as a healer and He never intended for His “super powers” to overshadow His message, but come on! Calming a storm is a big deal. Casting out a demon? Yeah, that’s newsworthy. Raising a child from the dead? That’s a front-page story with a banner headline if there ever was one! Why try and keep it quiet?

I took up the issue with my religion teacher as a teenager saying if Jesus were a little better at public relations things might have worked out a bit better for him in the end. “I don’t get it. He wanted people to believe in him, didn’t he?” I argued.

“Of course He did,” my teacher replied.

“Well, maybe if he would have been a little more forthcoming with his ‘abilities’ and didn’t talk in riddles as much, the chief priests and Pharisees would have believed in him and gotten with the program.”

“And then what?” my teacher challenged me.

“And then…nothing,” I shrugged.

“And then…nothing,” the teacher repeated, with extra emphasis on the last word.

Reality hit me like a ton of bricks. If Jesus had encouraged word to get out, if He would have shouted, “I am God” from the rooftops, if he would have rode into town like the cavalry and gotten everyone on board, He wouldn’t have died. He couldn’t have saved the world. He would have simply been stuck in it. As it was, He knew humans could not keep quiet about what they experienced and he counted on them to do their part and insure that He would be the sacrificial lamb He needed to be in order to fulfill His plan.

I won’t lie, I still struggle with the things Jesus said and did. I still shake my head at what appears to be inconsistencies in His ministry and I spend more than a little time trying to come up with a revisionist narrative that may have had a happier ending. However, that’s when I have to remind myself that no matter how much I ask; it’s unlikely He’s going to tell me the answers. If I stay solid in my faith, trust in His plan and use the gifts He has given me, one day I will be with Him in a much better place…and we will live happily ever after.

Today’s Mass Readings: MIC 2:1-5; PS10:1-2, 3-4, 7-8, 14; MT 12:14-21

 

About the Author

Julie Young is an award-winning writer and author from Indianapolis, Indiana in the USA, whose work has been seen in Today’s Catholic Teacher, The Catholic Moment, and National Catholic Reporter. She is the author of nine books including: A Belief in Providence: A Life of Saint Theodora Guerin, The CYO in Indianapolis and Central Indiana and The Complete Idiot's Guide to Catholicism. She is a graduate of Scecina Memorial High School in Indianapolis and holds degrees in writing and education from Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College. She can be found online at www.julieyoungfreelance.com

Author Archive Page

11 Comments

  1. Dear Julie,

    Thanks for being so frank in the very interesting reflection on the Gospels.

    I pray that God Bless You with serenity and peace in the struggle that you experience.

    Raymond

  2. Thanks, Julie, that added a new spark to my thoughts of His insistence on a sort of secrecy. I think, too, that if He had let it be shouted out “Here is the Messiah!” all the worldly interpretations of the Messiah would have been thrown at Him, to save the Jewish nation from all oppression etc, and since He was here for the bigger, the eternal saving, He would have been killed for failing to meet their expectations.
    God Bless!

  3. Thanks Julie for such a sober reflection.
    If we begin to request for an answer for every thing that Jesus did, we may not get it.
    I think the right thing is to remain firm in our faith and appreciate Him for all He did.

  4. Wow! The only word that entered my mind after reading your reflection. Praise God! Thank you Julie….

  5. I love when devotions cause me to ponder and this one will! It’s interesting because I have never reflected on these “inconsistencies” together. I’ve seen them as separate moments of humility or faith. I have had several studies where they have taught that at that time when Jesus said tell no one, it meant to go tell everyone. Ive honestly never considered there being another way. I appreciate the hope and tenderness you have Julie to want to protect Jesus from the outcome. Thank you for opening to me another persons thoughts. It will No doubt enlarge my own.

  6. Thank you, Julie! I have never understood those inconsistencies as well. I did like your conclusion after talking to your teacher. It makes sense to me now. But I know we may never get the whole picture… at least not while we are here on earth. Thanks for your reflection.

  7. There are moments with my walk with God that I go all four year old on Him with “Why? Why?” concerning Jesus’ ministry. Why did we have to have a sacrificial lamb in the first place? What is the point of ALL of this? Oops- there I go again! In my faith walk with Him, I have actually discovered that I am arrogant because I think I can understand the mind of God. I have always been humble enough to recognize that I may not have all the pieces right now but lately, I think I will never understand my Creator’s construction. I don’t say this with despair but with humility. God is just so much ahead of me that His methods and the path He lays out for each one of us is so perfect, that I, in my imperfect mind may never comprehend His Creation fully. This is when my faith in Him takes over and my trust in Him is challenged to grow- to realize that I may never figure it- and Him- out!

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published.