Saturday 2/23/19 I see dead people

It is one of the few events of Jesus’ life that I have never seen depicted on the big (or small) screen. It is an incident that juxtaposes His humanity and divinity, bends all of the known rules of the universe and offers concrete evidence that He is the Word made flesh. It is also the one mystery that perplexes me more than I care to admit. It is the transfiguration. 

            Whenever I think about the things that Jesus said and did during His time on Earth, I tend to put them in to two categories. There are the ones that defy all scientific explanation and point to the fact that He was God incarnate and then there are those that I assume are more symbolic or allegorical in nature, even if they look pretty miraculous on the surface. 

            But the Transfiguration is different and as I was contemplating this week’s reflection, I couldn’t help wondering aloud what it was about this one event that bothered me so much. Why do director’s shy away from it? They will make a crucifixion as bloody as humanly possible and blow their entire special effects budget to roll a stone away from a tomb…but they don’t touch the Transfiguration. 

            “What’s up with that?” I commented to my youngest son. 

            In his typical, no nonsense, and slightly offbeat way, he gave me an answer that, if I am being honest, just might be a little too close for comfort. “I don’t know but when you stop to think about it, Mom…some people just aren’t that comfortable with ghost stories.” 

            Is that what the Transfiguration is, a ghost story? A mass hallucination? A bizarre dream that was confused for reality? I don’t think so, but I also don’t know what to think. I have so many questions about this event I can’t hope to list them all here, but some of my favorites include: Why were only a few people invited to go on this field trip up the mountain?  What did Peter, John and James think when Jesus started his group chat with Moses and Elijah? How did they know it was Moses and Elijah in the first place? Were they wearing nametags? I don’t think the Bible offers a physical description of either man so how did they know what these gentlemen looked like? How was Peter able to talk to Jesus in his “Force Ghost” form? (That’s my analogy for it, but feel free to use your own.) Why was Peter’s first instinct to embark on a construction project to commemorate the event instead of saying, “How are you doing that?” And why would Jesus give anyone concrete proof that he was the Son of God and then forbid them from telling anyone about it – especially if that was a major point of His ministry? Seriously, am I the only person who has sat around thinking about this?

            As much as I would really like for there to be some kind of M. Night Shyamalan twist to this tale that will suddenly give me a “sixth sense” into it, I guess there isn’t one. It is a mystery in which the walls between the worlds were erased and three men experienced 2/3 of the Holy Trinity with their human senses. They saw Jesus for what He was and what He always has been and they learned how he is distinct from the “dead people” beside Him who were called to greatness. He exists in greatness because he is God’s son. One and the same. Separate AND Equal. It’s some pretty heavy stuff and maybe it just wouldn’t translate well if they tried to explain it at the time. Maybe it still doesn’t and that’s why directors avoid it. I don’t know the answer to that one either. What I do know is that despite having been given this incredible insight, one that was not magic, a freak of nature or some kind of special effect…the apostles’ faith wasn’t perfect. Mine isn’t either. I will always question the things I cannot understand. I will always look for the loopholes and sometimes even when the truth is staring right at me…I won’t know what to think and maybe that will keep me from tackling the subject until I have a better grasp on the material. 

Today’s readings for Mass: HEB 11:1-7; PS 145:2-3, 4-5, 10-11; MK 9:2-13

About the Author

Julie Young is an award-winning writer and author from Indianapolis, Indiana in the USA, whose work has been seen in Today’s Catholic Teacher, The Catholic Moment, and National Catholic Reporter. She is the author of nine books including: A Belief in Providence: A Life of Saint Theodora Guerin, The CYO in Indianapolis and Central Indiana and The Complete Idiot's Guide to Catholicism. She is a graduate of Scecina Memorial High School in Indianapolis and holds degrees in writing and education from Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College. She can be found online at www.julieyoungfreelance.com

Author Archive Page

10 Comments

  1. I see the Transfiguration as a glimpse of eternity, of that life beyond space and time wherein all live in the love of God. Maybe Peter, James and John knew with internal, spiritual certainty who Moses and Elijah were. And Peter just wanted to bring this eternal event into a context he could deal with, something on a smaller, human scale. In any case, I don’t think this was what Jesus’ ministry was all about. He never wanted to overawe us, to compel or frighten us into belief. He wanted, and wants us now, to love – to love God and love each other. That’s the point. The Transfiguration is just a sidelight, a glimpse of what it will be like, when (and if) we make it to heaven.

  2. I thought exactly the same thing “how did they know it was Moses and Elijah?”
    I have no answer. Thanks for your thoughts on this marvellous Gospel.

  3. The Transfiguration always fascinates me, too, and I too am always asking questions, particularly, what is it about? I can get why Peter wanted to build, to stay up there on the mountain in the glory of God, and I suppose he could guess that the two men were Elijah and Moses, who were noted for going up the mountain to meet with God. Who wouldn’t want to do that and stay there! And I wonder, too, when Jesus went off to pray on his own, was he transfigured with no one to witness it? And this time he brought witnesses, for a purpose . . . perhaps to encourage them, later, when all seemed lost. But I also think, like Bridged, this is a glimpse of eternity, God’s glory shining on earth.

  4. I’ve read it so many times that I just thought everybody knew each other…kind of like oh yeah its Moses and Elijah haven’t seen them for awhile. Now you that you break it down it really is a mystery and and possibly a glimpse of heaven. Awesome stuff Julie

  5. I think the transfiguration brings the old and new testament together and shows Jesus as the chosen one.

  6. Hey Julie,

    In my opinion, the Transfiguration, next to the Resurrection, is the most revealing miracle about Jesus. Period.

    But, as you have pointed out, I also have many questions concerning this miracle. So over the years I have asked a few priests and sisters what was the purpose of the Transfiguration. (In movie terms, it’s like a “spoiler alert” where Peter, James and John are given the meaning to the end of the movie. Why did Jesus do this?) I received varying answers, but probably the best answer was that it wasn’t about “why”, it’s about “when”.

    Something else for you to think about.

    Mark

  7. For me it’s a great example and lesson of FAITH. Some disciples were present to WITNESS it; and of course in time they shared this with the others too. Peter didn’t ‘know’ who Elijah and Moses were; but apparently Jesus or God let them to know it through their minds so they would realize that death was something relative only to life on earth. After all, both Moses and Elijah had been dead and gone to earth for a very long time; but here they were alive in human form and yet speaking with Jesus presumably from Heaven or at least a small part of Heaven merged with Jesus so the apostles could see and hear what was being done. It’s an extremely important lesson for the 3; so that once Jesus is crucified and then rises again, it will make more sense to them as they share it with the others. I can close my eyes and ‘see’ Jesus with the ‘dead’ Elijah and Moses, and then also to ‘hear’ the voice of God at the same time. My theory is that when Jesus rose again; these 3 completely understood that we would LIVE again in Heaven; that death on earth would not keep us from being resurrected with our Father and Jesus in Heaven. I’m also sure this was also certified in their minds when the Holy Spirit came to strengthen them as well. Don’t overthink it; just have FAITH and see if what I wrote doesn’t help make a little sense once you have the faith to start with. God bless us Julie and all of use who have NOT seen and yet BELIEVE!!!!!!

  8. Well Julie this is my very favourite Gospel reading. In my humble opinion I believe that Jesus in his humanness was fed up. Read the passages before his walk up the mountain. He probably needed to have a quiet time with his trusted friends to pray and talk. But his Heavenly Father knew he needed back up so asked Moses and Elijah to help him to stay with the programme. Let’s not forget that it was to his disciples that God spoke not Jesus. “This is my beloved Son. LISTEN TO HIM…

  9. I have to admit that I never really gave this reading much thought. I just accepted it as another miracle shown to some of the disciples. The questions raised by Julie and all of the comments have given me much to meditate on. This site is truly a blessing. Not just the writers, whom I greatly appreciate, but also the community. The comments offered provide so many different perspectives from many different walks in life. Thank you, all for your input. God bless.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *