Saturday September 19, 2020: Let Those Who Have Ears, Hear

Parable: a short fictitious story that illustrates a moral attitude or a religious principle

There were once two sisters, let’s call them Elizabeth and Sarah, who grew up in the Midwestern part of the United States. They each had the goal of making it in Hollywood. Of becoming a star. And they pursued these dreams relentlessly, moving to California when they graduated from high school. They worked endless shifts at various jobs to earn money to keep that dream alive.

As is often the case, the lure of the seductive life of Hollywood gained a foothold and each became pregnant out of wedlock. They each realized what the effect of the pregnancy would have on the career aspirations. It was very likely that having a child would derail what each had hoped to accomplish from those early days back home growing up. How could they let this one mistake result in the loss of everything? But…what about the child gaining life within? What of its aspirations and hopes? Its dreams?

Elizabeth was a beauty and was extremely talented. Everyone in the entertainment industry told her she was going places. Sarah was no slouch either. While her career had not yet taken off, all who knew her saw that her will and determination would pay off in the end. But this is where the paths that they traveled would diverge. Life changing decisions would be made.

Elizabeth chose to end her pregnancy. All her friends told her that it would be crazy to let this little thing end such a promising career. It would be simple to take care of. She was given several recommendations of where to go. She had support from her friends and it was done in a matter of a few hours.

Sarah took a different direction. She kept her child. It was hard. And to make it even harder, the child was born with Down’s Syndrome. She was a single mother in a town where that is far from the norm. At least in the circles that frequented Hollywood. And her child had a disability that was obvious to the world. She became an outsider. No one would give her work as an actress and her part time jobs could not now support her and her child. She decided to give up her dream. She decided to die to what made her..her. The dream of being on stage or in the movies was who she was and now it was gone. She returned home and received the support of her family and friends.

During this time Elizabeth grew into the actress all predicted she would be. She had it all. Money, fame, power and adoration from her fans. She even won an academy award for one of the films she starred in. Apparently, she made the right decision all those years ago. And she told the audience at the Oscars just that. How proud she was to have ended her pregnancy. It allowed her to fulfill her passion. To receive her reward and reach her dreams.

And Sarah? Her child grew as well. She was named Jamie. And wouldn’t you know it, she wanted to become an actress. She studied and rehearsed. Got cast in school plays. Was chosen for some commercial work. And then she was noticed by an agent who found her a role on a hit TV series. She was universally loved and found more roles and achieved the success that her mom had dreamed about.

Jamie took her success and used it to help those afflicted with Down Syndrome. She served as spokesperson for several organizations pledged to increase awareness of those with Downs in the community. She was successful in getting legislation passed to reduce discrimination for those with the genetic abnormality. What she had accomplished made her Mom swell with pride. She could not have imagined all those years ago what her pregnancy would have led to. To what this little soul inside of her would become.

“Truly, truly, I say to you, unless a grain of wheat falls into the earth and dies, it remains alone; but if it dies, it bears much fruit. 25 He who loves his life loses it, and he who hates his life in this world will keep it to life eternal.” (John 24-25)

Which sister received the most of God’s mercy, compassion and love? God’s love is boundless and never ending. They both received a wellspring of grace from the Lord. And are not we called to imitate what God provides? Each sister chose a different path. One could debate the factors that led to each choice. But, in the end, we are to take the mercy and love God shows us and extend it to those we meet along this journey.

About the Author

Hello! My name is John Ciribassi. I live in Carol Stream, IL in the USA. My wife Elise and I are parishioners at Corpus Christi Catholic Church. We have two adult daughters. One lives in Senegal, West Africa with her husband and her 3 sons. The other teaches Anthropology at the University of Oslo, Norway. We also have a home in Mainesburg, Pa in the North Central part of Pennsylvania. My wife and I are both retired veterinarians, and my specialty is in animal behavior. I attended college and veterinary school in Illinois, where I met my wife who is from the Chicago area, and the rest is history! My hobbies include Racquetball, Pickleball, Off Road Motorcycle Riding, Hiking and Camping. I continue to enjoy the opportunity to offer what little insight I have on the scriptures. But I have always felt that the scriptures can speak for themselves. My job is just to shine a little light on them for people who maybe don't have the time to look into the readings deeply. I hope you enjoy and find value in my writings. I continue to be grateful for this opportunity.

Author Archive Page

14 Comments

  1. Thank you, John. Sometimes God gives us the joy of seeing the happy results of our hard, but good decisions. But sometimes it will only be in the next life that we find out what good has come from them.

  2. I fail to see the moral of your story, John. What about Elizabeth’s child who was murdered just so that the mother could selfishly follow her ambitions?

  3. Interesting John.
    Helen, sometimes I feel God does hide our purpose in this life but shall be told in the next life.
    George, if that’s what you take from the story then that is the moral of the story for you.

  4. What is the moral attitude of religious principle of this story? I am confused. How does the scripture of a grain of wheat tie this together? I am confused and a bit outraged with this story coming from a writer on this website, so I need some clarification.

  5. Perhaps part of the moral is to not judge others and to show God’s mercy even if you do not agree with someone’s choices.

  6. Elizabeth’s faith was choked by weeds while Sarah’s grew in fertile soil.Hence the decision that each one made.In the end,who was the spiritually richer of the two?
    That’s my understanding of John’s reflection.

  7. I also cannot tie up today’s readings with the story. However, we have seen God’s mercy exhibited in both cases. Who are we to judge?

  8. This story exhibits the gift of discernment that each of us receives through the sacrament of confirmation. The Holy Spirit is always ready to assist and provide the blueprint in making decisions in life. Absence of this or lack of it one applies free wheeling of the intellect all surrounded with inadequacies. It spoke volumes of the importance of the gift of wisdom.

  9. I have struggled to not jump in and “reveal” my thoughts on this posting. But a parable is meant to stimulate discussion and it is intended to communicate different messages depending on the one doing the hearing. What I did not want to do is squash those things by jumping in too early. First of all, I would like to affirm that I am solidly pro-life. Abortion is a grievous sin. It is the murder of the pre-born..of innocent life. But I also wanted to show with the story that for many, the decision to terminate a pregnancy does not come easily. For some it is a selfish and indifferent act but for others it is a soul searching and spirit damaging choice. One that many pay the price for, especially the child victim.

    But my story was also meant to say how God’s mercy and forgiveness is infinite. That even the most serious of sins, is forgiven by God to the one who comes to the understanding of the nature of that sin and is truly repentant. And if God can forgive the worst of sins, can we not also follow the example He sets for us. Mercy and forgiveness grow out of love. The love we should all have for each other.

    Finally, Sarah gave up her dream. Gave up a piece of herself. She died to herself and in the process gave life to Jamie who then shared her fruits with the world. That seed that died when Sarah made the decision to keep her baby grew abundantly in Jamie and beyond. It is what happened to the seed that fell on fertile soil. The single seed died, no longer existed in its original form. But only through this death could growth have occurred.

    Let those who have ears, hear.

  10. Well John, thanks for your response. However, in your story, Elizabeth certainly showed no remorse or repentance and I was left feeling she sacrificed her child for her own success. Then you ended with a scripture that whoever loves their life will lose it. There appeared no mercy for her.

  11. Jan
    Yes, you are correct about Elizabeth. I actually modeled her from Busy Phillips. The actress who shouted out her joy at aborting her child while her career was getting started. Her character is contrasted with Sarah who gave up her career to raise her child. She died to herself in order for the life within her to grow and grow abundantly. She was the seed that died. She gave up her life to have life to the full eternally. The mercy Sarah received was her entrance through the narrow gate when her time comes. We may not be rewarded in this life for our sacrifices but will be in the next. But, regardless of the decisions made, we should show love and mercy to all. Elizabeth made a bad choice, but she is still a child of God and is due the same love God shows to us. We can only hope that she sees the light of God in us, recognizes her sin, and returns to the Father before the end of her days.

  12. My ears don’t work so well. After years of increasing hearing loss when hearing aids became no longer effective for me, I received a marvelous scientific and medical blessing, a cochlear implant. While this device is far from perfect and does not compare to natural hearing, it allows me to understand most speech in one-on-one conversations in quiet, noise free environments. Currently I struggle with the difficult decision of choosing whether to again, three years later, undergo surgery for a second, bilateral implant. I have come to learn through all of this that hearing is not to be taken for granted and that hearing and understanding are two entirely different thing. Jesus – rabbi, teacher and God – used parables unambiguously to deliver truths and instruct. No relativism. May God bless you, John, and all who write for “A Catholic Moment”, abundantly for assistance and instruction to understand His words and our faith! Thank you, John, for your followup comments and clarification to the story about Elizabeth and Sarah! I needed to hear you say that Elizabeth did make a bad choice and that abortion is murder of an innocent life. Nonetheless, we must show love, mercy and forgiveness to ALL people but hate and avoid sin and wrongdoing.
    Let those who have ears, hear the truth and discern the will of God!

  13. Mercy is mercy is mercy. No matter who we are or what we have done, it is God’s to give. Jesus forgave while dying on the cross. We pray for Mary to show us mercy and we helped put her son on that cross.
    God have mercy on all of us and help us to show others the mercy and compassion that we receive from you each moment of our lives.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *